|
The Sound Investor Series #7
Click
here for printer friendly version
(Click
here to refresh this site)
Investing 101 - Forwards and Backwards
Ed Hynes, CFA
July 12, 2005
Everyone has been told a thousand times how they "should"
invest. But for many people managing their investments is a daunting
task. It is difficult to understand and honestly, pretty boring.
So let's have some fun and turn your portfolio into a summer detective
mystery.
To be a good detective you need to understand events looking forward
and backwards. Let's start by briefly looking at the investment
process going forward.
| 1. |
Asset Allocation. This is where an investor
decides how they will divide their money among various asset
classes, such as stocks, bonds and cash. |
| 2. |
Choosing Risk in Each Asset Class. Within
each asset class investors decide what risks to take. For instance
what risk do they want in the stock market? Do they want board
exposure to the market or just to certain sectors such as technology? |
| 3. |
Investment Strategies. For each risk identified
in step 2, investors need to choose an investment strategy to
take that risk. For our purposes today this is primarily a question
of deciding between active and passive investment strategies.
Active investment strategies attempt to beat the market while
passive strategies aim to perform in line with the market. |
| 4. |
Purchase Investments. The final step is
to purchase individual stocks/bonds or other investments which
fit your investment strategies at a reasonable cost. |
Now for the fun as we become detectives in "CSI Wall Street."
Let's start with an example where your job is to figure out the
investment strategies of two, 50 year old men. Your only evidence
is their brokerage statements or what they did in step 4.
We see that "Investor A" owns about 20 energy and bio-tech
stocks. He also owns five mutual funds, all of which use active
investment strategies. All of "A's" assets are in stocks,
he has no cash or bonds. Expenses and fees cost him about 1.75%
a year.
"Investor P" on the other hand owns two Exchange-Traded
Funds (ETFs). Both are broad-based and one tracks the stock market
and the other the bond market. We see that "P" holds cash
in a money market for emergencies, and of his remaining money about
70% is in stocks and 30% in bonds. Expenses and fees cost "P"
about 0.50% a year.
The first thing our detective realizes is that "Investor A"
gets his name from using Active investment strategies and "Investor
P" from using Passive strategies.
Since "A" uses multiple active investment strategies,
we know he thinks he is one of the chosen few that can beat the
market. We see his stock selection is tilted toward the hot energy
and bio-tech sectors. He then increases his risk by choosing individual
stocks in these sectors. We guess he thinks if he picks the best
stocks in the best sectors he is going to get rich.
It is clear that "Investor A" never learned to save for
a rainy day as he has no cash for emergencies. Maybe he'll be lucky,
but most of us will need a rainy-day fund someday. He also doesn't
know or care about the benefits of portfolio diversification as
he has no bonds.
"Investor P" is a model investor according to our detective.
His asset allocation looks reasonable for a 50 year-old. He has
set aside money for emergencies and his remaining assets are split
70% stocks and 30% bonds. He realizes that asset allocation is the
most important decision when it comes to long-term returns and that
diversification is very important.
Within each asset class, i.e. stocks and bonds, he is well diversified,
as both ETFs are broad-based and own many different stocks or bonds.
With his passive strategy, "Investor P" will probably
trail the market by a very small amount, but it is highly unlikely
he will fall short by a significant amount. "Investor A's"
risks are almost the mirror image. He may beat the market from time
to time, but it is highly likely that over the long-term he will
under-perform "Investor P" by a large amount.
Now pull out your portfolio and play detective. What do your holdings
tell you about the decisions you have made?
Ed Hynes, CFA, is President of Farm Creek based
in Rowayton, CT. (203) 838-1025. This series of articles is available
at farmcreeksecurities.com. Before putting money in any investment,
you should carefully consider your investment objectives; and the
risks, charges and expenses of any investment. Past performance
is not an indication of future performance and there are risks to
investing including the loss of principal.
© Copyright 2005
| Back to the top
| Back to the previous page
|
This site uses frames to navigate. If you do not
see the navigation menu on the left part of your screen, please
click here to refresh this site.
© 2004 Farm Creek. All rights reserved.
Unauthorized access is prohibited.
|